Tests of moderation of the big-fish-little-pond effect across students with and without special educational needs in regular versus special education schools

Lohbeck, Annette, Gilbert, William ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6152-8656, Kocaj, Aleksander, Jansen, Malte et Morin, Alexandre J. S. (2024). Tests of moderation of the big-fish-little-pond effect across students with and without special educational needs in regular versus special education schools. Learning and Instruction, 93 .

PDF Document sous embargo jusqu'au 20 juin 2026. Licence d'utilisation : CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. Télécharger (871kB)

Résumé

Background
Inclusive education has become increasingly popular based on the assumption that it has multiple benefits for students with special educational needs (SEN). However, contradictions remain regarding the widespread nature of these benefits, particularly when it comes to academic motivation.
Aims
In this large-scale cross-sectional study, we relied on the Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect (BFLPE) to assess the links between inclusive education and students’ academic self-concepts and learning interests in the mathematics and verbal domains.
Sample
The sample consisted of 21,219 German elementary school children in Grade 4 who were enrolled in three groups: students without SEN attending regular schools (n1 = 19,069), students with SEN attending regular schools (n2 = 933), and students with SEN attending special education schools (n3 = 1214).
Methods
Doubly latent multi-group multilevel structural equation models and tests of latent interaction were performed to test the BFLPE.
Results
Results supported the BFLPE for both outcomes and domains. However, no BFLPE was identified for learning interest in the verbal domain among students with SEN attending special education schools, although the size of this effect did not differ significantly from that observed among students without SEN. In regular schools, the BFLPE was almost two times stronger among students with SEN than among their peers without SEN.
Conclusions
Results support the generalizability of the BFLPE to students with SEN, while casting doubts on the motivational benefits of inclusive education for these students. Interventions targeted at attenuating the BFLPE should thus be tailored for both regular and special education schools. -- Keywords : Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect (BFLPE) ; Academic self-concept ; Learning interest ; Special educational needs ; Inclusive education.

Type de document :	Article
Validation par les pairs :	Oui
Mots-clés :	Effet gros poisson-petit bassin ; Perception de soi ; Intérêt (Psychologie) ; Motivation en éducation ; Intégration scolaire ; Éducation spéciale.
Départements et unités départementales :	Département des sciences de la santé > Psychologie
Date de dépôt :	24 sept. 2024 20:27
Dernière modification :	24 sept. 2024 20:27
URI :	https://semaphore.uqar.ca/id/eprint/2989